Tuesday, November 3, 2009 ÜMİT ENGİNSOY ANKARA - Hürriyet Daily News American-Armenians and their congressional backers are keen on the ‘genocide’ recognition, not the creation of normalized ties between Turkey and Armenia, diplomats and experts say. Armenians will try to persuade the world that it's the Turks that stopped the process, an expert argue
Armenian-Americans and their backers in Congress are hoping for the collapse of a normalization deal between Turkey and Armenia so they can continue to lobby for U.S. recognition of what they term the "Armenian genocide," diplomats and analysts said.
The Turkish and Armenian foreign ministers signed historic protocols on Oct. 10 that called for the creation of normal diplomatic relations between the two neighbors and the reopening of their shared land border. Their parliaments must first ratify the deal before the provisions go into effect.
Before reopening the land border, which has remained closed for 16 years, Turkey wants to see some progress toward the resolution of the Nagorno-Karabakh problem between Armenia and Azerbaijan, Ankara's close ally.
Nagorno-Karabakh, a mainly Armenian-populated enclave inside Azerbaijan’s borders, has been under Armenian occupation since a war in the early 1990s.
Reopening border key matter
Yerevan, however, seeks to keep the normalization deal with Turkey and the Nagorno-Karabakh issue as completely separate processes, urging Turkey to reopen the border as soon as possible. Diaspora Armenians, meanwhile, also staunchly oppose any concessions on Karabakh.
But without progress on the Karabakh matter, it will be extremely difficult for Ankara to move to reopen the border. "If there's no progress on Karabakh, Turkey simply can't reopen the border with Armenia, which will effectively mean that the reconciliation process will have failed," one Washington-based analyst said. "If this happens, it will be important to see which side will be blamed for the derailed process. The Armenians will try to persuade the world that it's the Turks that stopped the process."
In that case, U.S. Armenians and their backers in Congress will seek to punish Turkey in Congress, the analyst said.
Armenian efforts in Congress
A resolution urging the United States to recognize the World War I-era killings of Armenians in the Ottoman Empire as genocide has been pending in the House of Representatives, Congress' lower chamber, since February.
Democratic Senator Robert Menendez and Republican Senator John Ensign introduced a similar resolution in the Senate, Congress' upper chamber, last month.
"Pro-Armenian lawmakers in both sides of Congress will step up efforts for genocide recognition in the event of the collapse of the Ankara-Yerevan deal," said the analyst.
"Any formal U.S. genocide recognition would kill the normalization process," one Turkish diplomat said.
But U.S. Armenians and their congressional backers are keen on genocide recognition, not the creation of normalized Ankara-Yerevan ties," said the analyst.
"So there's a major trap jeopardizing the reconciliation process, and that trap can be prevented only if there's progress on the solution of the Nagorno-Karabakh dispute," the analyst said.
Fuck the american armenian diaspora. Fuck them. And fuck them again.
Kayakiran- 11-03-2009
Westy, now, now now. Remember we are ALL armenians...
...just sayin'
Where Katas when you need an opinion from him?
katastrof- 11-03-2009
Sarkisyan was practically destroyed by diaspora Armenians everywhere he went last month. So this is nothing new, and also, who gives a flying fuck what the diaspora does? If they care about this so much, they should try spending a month or so in Armenia before yelling out like monkeys about Armenian foreign policy.
I think it'd be best if diaspora Armenians and Turks shut their mouths for good about Armenia and Turkey.
...just sayin'.
Kayakiran- 11-03-2009
QUOTE (katastrof @ November 03, 2009 04:19 pm)
Sarkisyan was practically destroyed by diaspora Armenians everywhere he went last month. So this is nothing new, and also, who gives a flying fuck what the diaspora does? If they care about this so much, they should try spending a month or so in Armenia before yelling out like monkeys about Armenian foreign policy.
I think it'd be best if diaspora Armenians and Turks shut their mouths for good about Armenia and Turkey.
...just sayin'.
So you're saying I have no right to voice my opinion about Turkish / armo relations since I live in the diaspora for now? Can you explain to me why?
...just askin'
katastrof- 11-03-2009
QUOTE (Kayakiran @ November 03, 2009 05:51 pm)
So you're saying I have no right to voice my opinion about Turkish / armo relations since I live in the diaspora for now? Can you explain to me why?
...just askin'
I'm not talking about your "right" to do anything. What I wrote is pretty clear and doesn't require anyone to put any spin on it.
Kayakiran- 11-03-2009
QUOTE (katastrof @ November 03, 2009 05:09 pm)
I'm not talking about your "right" to do anything. What I wrote is pretty clear and doesn't require anyone to put any spin on it.
No, it's not clear. Expand on your opinion as to why the respective diasporas should shut their mouths about it. You simply said that we need to shut our collective mouths but didn't didn't cite any reasons why we should. What spin are you talking about?
katastrof- 11-03-2009
QUOTE (Kayakiran @ November 03, 2009 06:15 pm)
No, it's not clear. Expand on your opinion as to why the respective diasporas should shut their mouths about it. You simply said that we need to shut our collective mouths but didn't didn't cite any reasons why we should. What spin are you talking about?
Because the diasporas don't have any immediate stakes on this matter, and they should leave the decisions to people who actually do.
That aside, let me clarify a little bit of the subtext here. Let me ask you, why do you seem to be itching to get into a new confrontation with me? You have been throwing unprovoked lashes at me under many threads, and for no apparent reason since you started posting again.
I am telling you right now, and nicely: If that's what you are after, I have better things to do with my time, and I am not interested.
artist- 11-03-2009
QUOTE
We Are All Armenians
sorry but when the other one died i didnt even feel myself armenian, not even 1% Armenians r liar, brainwashed, attention whores Not only turks dislike em Azeri nd Georgians do hate em too .
I preefer to be a citizen of Hell instead of being an armenian sneak
artist- 11-03-2009
And they dunno what's a dialogue bcuz they r stubborn, they will start to critize a whole nation for their "genocide" with their wet eyes and for vacation they fly in Van and tell they love Van and Its an armenian town etc..
I ALWAYS SAID THAT THE GREEK WASNT THE ENNEMY BUT THE ARMENIAN IS A TRUE ONE
Evropeos- 11-03-2009
QUOTE (artist @ November 04, 2009 12:35 am)
Azeri nd Georgians do hate em too.
Azeris hate Armenians?Shit, that was totally new to me.
Kayakiran- 11-03-2009
QUOTE (katastrof @ November 03, 2009 05:23 pm)
Because the diasporas don't have any immediate stakes on this matter, and they should leave the decisions to people who actually do.
That aside, let me clarify a little bit of the subtext here. Let me ask you, why do you seem to be itching to get into a new confrontation with me? You have been throwing unprovoked lashes at me under many threads, and for no apparent reason since you started posting again.
I am telling you right now, and nicely: If that's what you are after, I have better things to do with my time, and I am not interested.
QUOTE
Because the diasporas don't have any immediate stakes on this matter, and they should leave the decisions to people who actually do.
You should be more specific and say "most of those in the armo diaspora" because most of those in the armo diaspora do not have a direct stake in the matter because most have about a zero tie to armenia because armenia is a brand new entity, no? Not so with the Turkish diaspora.
I do not have numbers to back up the following statement but I would venture to guess that at least 50% of the Turkish diaspora have solid ties and taxable investments in Turkey. Moreover, we travel to Turkey and visit our "stakes" on a regular basis. If anyone should shut their mouth it is the armo diaspora.
QUOTE
That aside, let me clarify a little bit of the subtext here. Let me ask you, why do you seem to be itching to get into a new confrontation with me? You have been throwing unprovoked lashes at me under many threads, and for no apparent reason since you started posting again.
You're reading too much into the non existent subtext here. Those "lashes" you've been fielding are nothing but inane banter. If I really didn't like you at all you would be ignored and rendered persona non grata (sorry no hyperlink)
QUOTE
I am telling you right now, and nicely: If that's what you are after, I have better things to do with my time, and I am not interested.
Thanks for being polite. Did you ever consider that I actually wanted your opinion on the matter in place of cruising for a confrontation.
Please continue....
artist- 11-03-2009
QUOTE (Evropeos @ November 04, 2009 12:43 am)
Azeris hate Armenians?Shit, that was totally new to me.
lol really or r you doing your pinocchio??
Sure they do,do you know howmany azeris died bcuz of em, they burned their mosques, raped their woman, killed their kids and when they across an azeri they tell it with a big smile like the morons they r
katastrof- 11-03-2009
QUOTE (Kayakiran @ November 03, 2009 06:48 pm)
Thanks for being polite. Did you ever consider that I actually wanted your opinion on the matter in place of cruising for a confrontation.
Please continue....
Actually, I frankly didn't think that. And let's be honest, it wouldn't be the rational presumption on my part, would it?
Anyway, thanks for the correction.
You (and anyone else for that matter) should know that I don't come here to make enemies, but I do to make friends. Also, I don't care whether the friends I make are leftists, nationalists, anarchists, communists, islamists, or whatever other -ists, as long as they have the same attitude.
Kayakiran- 11-03-2009
QUOTE (katastrof @ November 03, 2009 06:38 pm)
Actually, I frankly didn't think that. And let's be honest, it wouldn't be the rational presumption on my part, would it?
Anyway, thanks for the correction.
You (and anyone else for that matter) should know that I don't come here to make enemies, but I do to make friends. Also, I don't care whether the friends I make are leftists, nationalists, anarchists, communists, islamists, or whatever other -ists, as long as they have the same attitude.
Okay then...let's look forward to a good future. But I still think you were the one who clicked on "Writhe Kaya" in my poll.
..or duke.
Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.