Full Version : Christians = traitors
greekturkish >>Greek and Turkish Forum >>Christians = traitors


<< Prev | Next >>

Klarceti- 07-23-2008
Thank you very much, Red greekturkish/smile.gif

katastrof- 07-23-2008
Great post, Klarceti, nice to see you here.

I have a comment about Akcam, but I'll open a new topic about that. By "acute problem", do you mean the Armenian genocide, or something else?

Klarceti- 07-24-2008
QUOTE (katastrof @ July 24, 2008 04:50 am)
Great post, Klarceti, nice to see you here.

I have a comment about Akcam, but I'll open a new topic about that. By "acute problem", do you mean the Armenian genocide, or something else?

Thanks Katastrof. greekturkish/smile.gif
No, I actually meant the situation of the Christian minority in general, which is not very rosy in general.
Especially with the massive islamisation and the rise of racism within the younger generation of Turkey, their situation gets more and more worse.
We have several hundred thousand Armenian workers in Turkey.
Most live illegally there, some even for more than a decade. Making their status clear is a very important issue. Also the situation of the Jewish, Armenian and Greek minority needs to be improved. If these people can be fully integrated into the Turkish society (and with integration I mean integration and not assimilation), they could be a balancing power against rising islamisation aspirations.
Anyway as far as I could see up to now, it was the non-Muslims of Turkey who were much more concerned with the country, the republic and her principles than the average Muslim Turk.

Nikephoros- 08-06-2008
Now the differences between the Turkish populace(in Turkey) vs. the Turkish posters existing in this forum are mainly:

1)every Turk has to know English
2)many Turks here live outside of Turkey in countries much more tolerant

Basically in this thread I tried to provide only a small glimpse with a few sources for how Christian minorities fare in Turkey.

Two Turkish posters responded immediately and confirmed my thread seeder with their responses:
Los Magnados (to say it is true, because they are traitors)
turkkan (to distort everything I said in my post and say it is true because Maronites are all spies when the source presents generally how Christians minorities are treated default as "traitors")

From an old thread:
QUOTE (Lethe @ March 17, 2008 03:42 pm)
if a tourko fights with a tourist he/she judged in state security courts instead of regular court...  greekturkish/Yes.gif  


This fact explains why a fanatic muslim nation like Turkey is able to receive so many tourists. In Turkey the internal "Christian co-citiziens": (mostly Greeks and Armenians, but if they were real citiziens the state would not actively persecute them solely for being of a different religious confession) are actively stereotyped very negatively and are treated horribly by the state and populace at large. If the tourists were treated half as bad they would never come.

Or maybe tourists visiting Turkey can be treated just like "Kurdish citiziens" and made to feel/be/speak Turkish(if they were real citiziens at all the state would not care).

Arabas Perna- 08-06-2008
Again, religion divides and breeds hatred and segregation.

Nikephoros- 08-10-2008
The Compass direct News page for Turkey.

This link gives a good glimpse at the recent climate of persecution against the small barely tolerated Christian minority in Turkey which is created by the popular newspapers, TV stations, state officials, nationalist parties.

optimaton- 08-10-2008
QUOTE (Arabas Perna @ August 06, 2008 07:30 pm)
Again, religion divides and breeds hatred and segregation.

lol, this is like the 23rd time you've posted this unsubstantiated generalisation. greekturkish/bluebiggrin.gif

Once again, young arabas, are you implying that a world without religion would mean none of the above as well as no more wars, poverty or Jerry Springer type of talk shows.

And this coming from a poster who goes on and on about Shamanism and once had a sig that read "Pagan Pride".


Emre- 08-10-2008
QUOTE (Nikephoros @ August 10, 2008 08:50 pm)
The Compass direct News page for Turkey.

This link gives a good glimpse at the recent climate of persecution against the small barely tolerated Christian minority in Turkey which is created by the popular newspapers, TV stations, state officials, nationalist parties.

Thanks chump, I'll make sure to follow your link on regular basis...

Please allow me to return the favour by sharing some of my bookmarks with you. I think you will find them very helpful. I didn't go to the trouble of finding their direct links to Turkey though, please accept my apologies. <> Zoltan !!! <>

http://thepersecutiontimes.com/
http://www.christianpersecution.info/
http://www.persecution.org/suffering/index.php
http://www.persecution.com/
http://persecutionblog.com/
http://www.christianmonitor.org/

domestos- 08-14-2008
QUOTE (Emre @ July 22, 2008 06:32 am)
Tell me, in what way Kurds were treated any different to other ethnic groups, including Turks, in Turkey.

It's a bit late but i'd like share a sentence i liked. Kurds were given only one right in Turkey. The right of being a Turk.

LOS MAGANDOS- 08-15-2008
QUOTE (Nikephoros @ August 06, 2008 08:46 am)
This fact explains why a fanatic muslim nation like Turkey is able to receive so many tourists.


greekturkish/laugh.gif greekturkish/laugh.gif greekturkish/laugh.gif

Nikephoros- 08-20-2008
double

Nikephoros- 08-20-2008
Nutuk (Mr. let's "Bomb their whole goddam race") brought this article to my attention from a post of his on WAFF accompanied by his Kemalist bravado.

I made comments of my own surronded by brackets [ ] and boldened, to respond select claims and certain points. Compared/constrasted to how minorities are actually treated in Turkey, this article is just bitching, whining and moaning:

QUOTE ("SELAHATTİN SEVİ @ Zaman")

Turkish minorities on Greek Aegean islands deprived of their rights

... Milonas'[local Greek Alderman] report draws attention to the issue of foundations issue, which is also a matter of debate on Rhodes. He criticizes the practice of electing foundations' boards of directors in elections that are closed to the public and far from transparency, since the five executive board members of Turkish foundations are chosen by Greek authorities. Some serve for a set period of time and some serve for life. These foundations, ruled by people not chosen by the Turkish population, work as institutions for discharging real estate on the two islands, leaving 40 properties belonging to Turkish foundations in Rhodes out of an original 450. ...

[I have no idea what this criticism even means since the members of any minority or religious group do not "elect" people to deal with their property.]

Demands of the Turkish communities on Rhodes and Kos:
[Probably these are Turkey's demands (and the demands of Turks in Rhodes/Kos who will help the Turkish Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Turkish embassies and consulates in Greece with their agenda.)]

Turkish and Islamic education should be provided at schools.

Turkish schools, particularly the Süleymaniye Madrasa on Rhodes, which was closed in 1972, should be reopened.

[If they mean importing racist fanatical Turkish Ministry of Education textbooks and teachings, they can make three fingers and stick them in any major bodily orifice. The purpose of this education is to make "soldier citiziens" to carry out "national goals"(which include the Turkish Ministry of Foreign Affairs agenda against Greece).]

A community representative and the post of mufti should be granted again, as it was during Italian rule.

Incomes of the foundations should be used for the foundations and high taxes should be lightened.
[Islam is not some angelic religion and never was and never will be. Islam is a total system that has political, economic and religious elements, it is a total system and ideology that embraces every moment and every activity. So Islam is a very dangerous system, that is involved somehow in most world hot-spots for feuling the conflict.

I do not even really know what a specifically what a mufti is, but even in Turkey they are not elected. And if Greece had a mufti in Rhodes/Kos, Turkey would bring a new complaint forward next about the mufti not being elected, since this is the tempo and method of Turkish diplomacy towards Greece.]


Transparency should be provided for the election of foundation administrations. Turks should elect their administrators themselves.
[Call human rights groups! No ethnic or other groups excercise direct democracy over such issues. Living in the USA all these years I never had a say over ethnic Greek stores, who controls Greek Orthodox Church properties or what Greek American associations do. Each association has its internal hierarchy and structure and for sure none of them gets its mandate from elections in the Greek American community at large. This novel practice is only registered to bourgeoise democracy; so fools can elect people(who represent business interests in the USA) and convince themselves they did something. This is an invented issue and just plain whining. This article has provides no evidence at all that the Greek state strips Turks there of their property.]

Historical artifacts should be restored. Imams and muezzins should be appointed to mosques.
[Huh? This article did not even build a case or mention historical artificats being stripped. All they did is complain that there were no elections for the Turks administering properties.]

Citizenship should be given back to islanders who were expatriated arbitrarily.
[Again the article built no case for this and made no mention. If they mean Turks who used to live in Rhodes but moved to Turkey for the past 20 years odd years, then good job on the Greek government there. Turkey is not some angelic nation like Norway; Hurriyet newspaper has for its motto: "Turkey for the Turks". Certainly Greece does not need alot of long-time residents of Turkey bringing that ethos to Greece to create the same problems which plague Turkey to this day.

Raven- 08-22-2008
QUOTE (domestos @ August 14, 2008 09:49 pm)
It's a bit late but i'd like share a sentence i liked. Kurds were given only one right in Turkey. The right of being a Turk.

where did you get this sentence from?

what period does it refer to?

Nikephoros- 09-06-2008
Let's compare a little the specific treatment of the Greek community of Istanbul by Turkey with the Greek treatment of the Turkish minority in the Aegean islands.

First the Greek:
user posted image
Source:
Vryonis, Speros. The Mechanism of Catastrophe: The Turkish Pogrom Of September 6-7, 1955, And The Destruction Of The Greek Community Of Istanbul. Greekworks.com (New York, 2005) p. 15.

Now back the relevant Zaman article:
QUOTE ("SELAHATTİN SEVİ @ Zaman")

Turkish minorities on Greek Aegean islands deprived of their rights
...
One most special Islamic features of Rhodes is the Muslim Library. It belongs to the Fethi Paşa Foundation, founded by Hafız Ahmet Ağa in 1792. The library contains more than 2,000 Turkish, Arabic and Persian manuscripts. The foundation has been popular with tourists. Showing off the invaluable manuscripts, the head of the foundation, Yusuf Kıbrıslı, says they pay attention to do their best to preserve the manuscripts, keeping a close watch on humidity and temperature.
...


Amazing, contrary to the main thesis of the article without the heavy intervention of the Turkish government like in Thrace as the article state:

QUOTE ("SELAHATTİN SEVİ @ Zaman")

Today they do not possess minority rights arising from international treaties, unlike West Thracian Turks, whose rights are relatively assured.


The Greek government overall does match the rotten behavior of Turkey, like when it closed the library of the Hellenic Philological Society of Constantinople, confiscated its books and prevents even to this day any Greek scholar from having access to these works.

Good job on Selahattin Sevi and Zaman for not proving their thesis: "Turkish minorities on Greek Aegean islands deprived of their rights" or the contention that Turks in the Aegean islands suffered from not having minority rights like "West Thracian Turks". In the past such agreements have never stopped a determined Turkey to deprive its Greek minority of its rights even when it contradicted the Turkish obligation according the Lausanne Treaty.


Nikephoros- 09-22-2008
The bias of Turkish courts against Christians can be seen from the below article. My comments are in parentheses () in italic.

QUOTE ("Turkish court bias in Christian slayings")

TURKEY: LAWYERS DEMAND REMOVAL OF MALATYA JUDGES
MALATYA, Turkey, February 28 (Compass Direct News) – Lawyers representing the families of three Christians tortured and slaughtered with knives in eastern Turkey last April demanded this week that the three-member bench of judges hearing the case be replaced.  ...

On April 18, 2007, five young Turkish Muslims entered the Malatya offices of Zirve Publishing, a distributor of Bibles and Christian literature, under false pretenses of wanting to study Christianity. The assailants tied up, tortured and then slit the throats of Necati Aydin and Ugur Yuksel, both Turkish Christians who had converted from Islam, and German Christian Tilmann Geske.
(Turkish muslims also slaughter livestock in the same manner on Bayram, maybe they also chanted "Allah Akbar" after killing these Christians.)

According to identical handwritten notes found in the pockets of all five killers, their motives were both nationalist and religious. “We did this for our country,” the notes read. “They are attacking our religion.”
(Despite the "Turkey promotion machine" and its hyping of Turkish secularism, apostates from Islam who go to Christianity are seen as a threat and should be killed like any apostate it appears to a large segment of the Turkish public. But Kemalist apostates(that is to say Kemalist atheists) are not killed because they are not real atheists, their religion is Turkism(Turkish nationalism) and the official ideology.)

...

Plaintiff lawyers have pro-*test*-('")ed repeatedly that the official court record contains only abbreviated summaries of their oral arguments and court witnesses.

At the outset of Monday’s hearing, the Malatya panel of judges again denied plaintiff requests to allow the hearings to be recorded. They also refused to release access to all the evidence gathered by the state prosecutors or to remove 16 files irrelevant to the killings, which in effect targeted people who had been in contact with the murdered Christians.


It was the Malatya judges’ third consecutive refusal of plaintiff requests to record the trial hearings ...

Court Withholding Evidence

Soylu also objected to the court’s refusal to grant access to a host of documents and other evidence, including the killers’ computer records, photographs from the autopsies and crime scene and security camera films from one suspect’s hospital room.


“This is essential information if we are to properly cross-examine the defendants,” Soylu stated. “It is illegal to not allow us to review this evidence.”

...

Questioning whether in fact vital evidence in the case had been destroyed, Soylu said, “We don’t have any trust in the court. There are many ‘lost’ details that are being withheld. We have the right to examine all the missing documents and pieces of evidence.”

...

Cengiz had requested police protection on February 8, after a series of overt threats against his life and clear-cut evidence that his telephones and e-mail correspondence were being tapped. Cengiz has served for eight years as legal counsel to the Turkish Alliance of Pro-*test*-('")ant Churches.
(Knowing the Turkish state and the precedents it has set in the past, it cannot be ruled out that these threats are really not coming from what appear to civil groups in society, but on closer inspection they are directed by the state appartus or elements in it.)


Last week two opposition deputies called for a parliamentary investigation into the recent attacks against Turkey’s Christian leaders and non-Muslims, declaring that these violent incidents were “neither accidental nor individual.”


Republican Party deputies Sukru Elekdag and Onur Oymen warned that if such attacks continued, Turkey’s image would be seriously damaged.
(Too bad the Greek government does not pay Public Relations firms worldwide a few million Euros to publicize the news of the flippant attitude of Turkish courts to Christians being murdered in Turkey because of the conspiracy theories and hatred the Turkish state(along with the judicial system), media and populace all fuel. The hit Turkey takes in tourism and credibility would be well worth any millions of Euros spent. Also when Turkey makes its persistent and constant claims in the Aegean against Greek territory, or of Greek human rights abuses(all to promote the Turkish foreign policy objectives), it will matter alot less. Because if Greece actively exposes the low credibility of Turkey instead of promoting Turkey's EU membership, the persistent claims of problematic neighbor Turkey against Greece will matter alot less.) 

...

In addition to the Malatya massacre, the report cited 19 specific incidents of intimidation and violence against their church leaders and buildings reported officially to Turkish security officials. The Pro-*test*-('")ants faulted ongoing “campaigns of provocation” inciting Turkish society against non-Muslim groups and portraying “missionary activity” as a crime, even at the highest state levels.


Free Forum Hosting by Forumer.comTM!